Evercore has been putting out some really good charts lately so I’m going to do another quick note on something interesting they published.

First, I should explain what “negative beta” means. Most of you probably know beta tells you how much of a stock’s move is due to the rise in the stock market rather than to something stock specific. If a stock always goes up when the market rises and falls when the market falls, it has a beta of 1 (that’s oversimplifying but close enough).

If a stock’s price change is completely uncorrelated to the market – so sometimes it goes up when the market rises, but sometimes it falls and vice versa when the broader market falls – it’s beta is 0.

But there are rare stocks that go down when the market goes up and rise when the market falls. These stocks have negative beta, i.e. they are inversely correlated. If a short seller hedge fund was a public company, you might imagine it would have a beta of -1.

More practically, you can think about what I wrote recently about insurance stocks being inversely correlated to data centers. Because the market is so tech heavy today, then anything that people buy when tech is down or sell when tech is up will end up having negative beta.

The Data

Why is this interesting? Because it isn’t just insurance stocks that have negative beta these days. It’s a lot of stocks. A lot of lot of stocks.

As you can see, most of the time only a handful of stocks have negative beta. Today, it is 191 of the S&P 500 stocks, nearly 40%! This is double the previous anomaly during…the end of the Tech Bubble. Yikes!!!

Similarly, by market cap, we are now at 27% of the S&P500 has negative beta, above the 26% high in the Tech Bubble.

Now, I should point out one caveat. Most of these stocks are a lot closer to 0 beta than -1. The biggest negative beta market caps are Berkshire (-.07 beta), Eli Lilly (-.05), and Walmart (-.12). Most of the other names are in that same general vicinity. “Negative” is doing some heavy lifting.

I didn’t notice any names above -0.5 beta. So it’s probably more accurate to say the market has more uncorrelated names than ever.

I don’t have data on the individual components back in 2000 but I would guess it was a similar phenomenon where “negative” was more like 0.

However, that does suggest there are probably a lot of +0.04 or +0.11 beta names that are also acting similarly, so the real number of “anti-tech” stocks may well be closer to half the index.

What Does It Mean?

Does this mean a market crash is imminent? For sure! 100%! Wait, no, it doesn’t mean any such thing. Just because something unprecedented has now become a precedent, doesn’t mean the second time will follow the first (got that?).

However, it is a cause of concern. This data is a sign of an unhealthy market structure. When you combine it with the stress on credit spreads for prominent tech companies, it becomes worrisome.

When we inevitably get to the end of the bubble, it will be easy to look at this chart as a prescient warning. However, bubbles tend to take longer to end that people expect them to so I am not ready to predict the end quite yet.

This reminds me, at the moment (subject to change on short notice and not investment advice!), of late 1998 where there was a mini-panic that the end was near which was then followed by one last massive runup higher. If there is one thing I’ve learned about calling bubble tops, it’s that it’s better to be a little late than a little early.

So what to do about this? For right now, probably nothing.

Be aware of it. File it away in the list of negatives to monitor. Understand it will eventually unwind – and more likely through lower stock prices than higher – and use it to build conviction in the bear case once we do get closer to the end of the cycle so you can act quickly when we get there.

4 thoughts on “Why You Should Be Worried About Negative Beta Stocks”

  1. And what are the actions you would undertake if we do get there re ‘the bear case?’

    Asking for a friend.

    1. ha well the good news if it’s a typical major bear market, it means AI didn’t kill us all but we just built too many data centers.

      The bad news is typically stocks would go down 30-50% (but possibly from a higher starting point than today) so you have to decide whether you’re comfortable riding that out or want to bail beforehand. Just don’t bail at the bottom like most people do!

      1. Is this “bubble” really comparable to the .com bubble?

        These are the largest’ richest and most well capitalized companies the world has ever seen and a technology that arguably dwarfs the internet era.

        I guess a good analogy is this is not a highly indebted/levered first time home buyer. These are instead extremely affluent first time home buyers consuming core market participation with levered buyers participating on the fringes. Good income flows with lots of equity in the house in the core buying market who are also propping up the fringe buyers as well.

        Hence you can make all the diagrams and point to all the metrics you want, but this particular market euphoria has very powerful legs. Meaning mood is a very powerful force here unlike other “comparable bubbles”.

        I think the central issue is the investors around the fringes are being propped up by the affluent buyers.

        Meaning the investors profiting in the current stage of the game (Nvidia) are also investing creatively in the later stages of the game and no one knows exactly how dangerous this dynamic is and to say they do is pure speculation and dishonest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *